Reblog from John from the old Earthshope.org site:
On November 10, 2007, I traveled with colleagues to the edge of the remnant Gishwati Forest in Northwestern Rwanda. What we found was heart wrenching. It’s taken some time to write this. I needed to come to grips with my feelings about what we had seen and what I thought about it.
In Rubavu District - Kazenze and in Nuyabihu District at Bigogwe, Jenda and Mukamira there were 9 days of heavy rain between Sept 12 and Sept. 20. Twenty people, mostly children and the elderly were killed in floods and mudslides that flowed down from the hillsides. It was the young and the old who couldn’t move fast enough to avoid the flood.
We arrived almost a month after the event but the place was still in ruins. The water and mud was everywhere. The survivors were sifting through the wreckage to salvage what they could. The children of course crowded around us when we came with our Jeep and cameras but they seemed somewhat subdued as if they had seen too much. They pointed to where their friends and family members had died and seemed to feel that such events were inevitable. Are they?


This was once the Great Gishwati Forest the second largest Forest in Rwanda. Now the Forest is just a tiny remnant of what it once was. Even this has been fragmented into small patches. Most of the trees have been cut and in their place are fields planted on the hillsides. Many are not terraced at all and the rows are sometimes even planted vertically up the hillside. There is no way that these hillsides could ever be extremely productive land. The result of trying to force these unsuitable areas to agriculture is a complex series of events that leads to flooding and mudslides.
The first result is the loss of ecosystem function. This is not a single thing but a complex web of interactions.
First to go is the massive generation of biomass (including the ability to sequester carbon), followed by the loss of necromass (the decaying plant litter) that would accumulate continuously. This means a loss of biodiversity with less flora and fauna and the genetic wealth that they represent, and this means less carbon uptake and less oxygen production.
The next loss is soil fertility. Within a very few seasons the natural fertility has been leached out of the soil and without the annual creation of biomass and necromass replenishing the soils, the nutrient cycle is broken.
Then the erosion begins in earnest and the top soils with the remaining organic matter and fertility flow off into the streams. Each time you look at the river systems in places where this is happening you see brown heavily silt laden waters.

This is the wealth of the nation flowing downstream. And sadly it won’t necessarily even enrich those downstream because the other major disruption is to the ability to infiltrate water during rainfall and retain it through the seasons. So this type of disruption heralds another problem.
Flooding causes drought.
When the waters rush off during the rainy season without infiltrating and being stored in the biomass and the necromass, then there is no absorption into the plant material and no respiration by the plants, not only altering the carbon uptake and oxygen levels but changing the soil moisture content and the relative humidity in the air. All this because the people of this region felt that they had no choice but to cultivate the land. And they are right - alone, left to their own devices and needing to survive they have little alternative.
But something has changed.
Thanks to the Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, the Stern Report and the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) reports, we know that human activity has disrupted ecosystem function on a planetary scale and that if we don’t restore these functions we will all suffer. The climate change debate’s focus may be on Greenhouse gas emissions but I can make a strong case that this is just one symptom of a much larger problem. The fact is that not only are we emitting carbon and other greenhouse gases but we have degraded vast areas of the planet ensuring that the Earth’s ability to absorb carbon, has in many places and to a large extent, been lost. Invariably, where this function has been lost you will find large numbers of poor people living hand to mouth in degraded ecosystems and not surprisingly these are the same places where flooding and mudslides can and do occur.
It seems to me that all the information we have points to the fact that the future of everyone on Earth will be determined by functional ecosystems on a planetary scale. This means that the people of Rwanda are not on their own in needing to protect these ecosystems. We are right there on the front line with them. The stakes are just too high to ask desperately poor illiterate people to take on the major responsibility. If you ask the question “Do they have the scientific understanding, technical ability, management capacity and capital to restore these areas?” The answer is no.
But interestingly, if you contemplate again the fact that everyone’s future depends on functional ecosystems on a planetary scale, and then you ask the question; “does the world have the scientific understanding, technical ability, management capacity and capital to restore these degraded lands?” Then the answer is most definitely, YES.
The pictures below are freeze frames from our documentation of the rehabilitation of the Loess Plateau in China. The screen on the left is the Ho Jia Gou Valley in 1995 and the one on the right is the same valley in 2005. We have seen and documented that it is possible to rehabilitate large-scale damaged ecosystems including restoring ecosystem function that had been lost over large areas and long periods of time.


Re-vegetating large areas of the planet offer us a huge opportunity. In China, it was necessary to move the people away from subsistence agriculture and to provide sufficient external investment and technical support. It worked and it can work elsewhere. If you understand the principles of ecosystem function (vegetation cover, soil microbiology, organic matter, carbon cycling and natural hydrological regulation) and you design human systems to interact but not disrupt these systems then it is possible to stop degrading and begin to restore functionality. This is exactly the knowledge we need right now to address climate change and a plethora of other problems.
So where do we start?
One idea might be to look at where there are high siltation rates from disrupted soils because the vegetation cover has been compromised. The very good people at Dartmouth Flood Observatory, using data from NASA, European Space Agency, JAXA and others have created maps and charts showing exactly where these areas are. There have been 231 floods worldwide so far in 2007, there are five flood events happening right now. Although some of the most devastating are Typhoons and Hurricanes, the impact from these types of storms would also be theoretically lowered by massive revegetation, especially the restoration of Mangrove forests along coastlines.

Find out more about the excellent work taking place at Dartmouth by clicking on the image.
I had to get my mind around what we saw in Rwanda because the tragedy of 20 people while quite terrible enough is only a small fraction of the problem. According to the Dartmouth data 8350 people have already died from flooding this year and 10’s of millions of people have been displaced (a nice way of saying - made homeless).

The photo on the left is of a flood that killed 10 in Costa Rica. The Photo on the right is of a flood that killed 45 in Haiti. Thousands were made homeless.
Many of these deaths and “displacements” can be avoided. The interesting thing about the fact that much of these problems are “human induced” is that if we learn and change our behavior we can change the outcome.
There is sufficient data to understand that re-vegetation of large areas of the planet would lessen the impact of storms reducing the severity of floods and mudslides. This would also help to sequester carbon. Especially in large fundamentally degraded ecosystems there is a very high up side. There would be many other positive benefits.
The world’s scientists are telling us that we can expect more and more extreme weather because we have so degraded ecosystem function on the planet. If you reverse the logic coming from the climate change warnings, then taking the concepts of re-vegetation, increasing organic matter in the soil, increased infiltration of moisture into soils and biomass, increased respiration by plants and soil organisms, to a massive scale; would help stabilize the weather. And theoretically, if we fully restored functionality should even be able to reduce the incidence of these types of events.
These things are measurable. We have excellent measurements of the level of degradation. What we need to be looking for is the inverse. The potential of rehabilitation and executing this on a planetary scale. When we get our minds around this then we can actually see that this is our opportunity to end poverty and restore many, if not all of the degraded landscapes wherever they are on the planet.
This seems to me to be the central issue of our time. We will either get this right or future generations will condemn us for having been so selfish and shortsighted that we did nothing.
Human understanding grows. This is true for individuals and for the species. In many cases it can take its time. But that does not seem to be the case with this knowledge. We are called upon to learn this immediately and heal our relationship with the planet.
Whatever we do we are determining what the future will be. If we ignore this then we are consciously accepting the suffering of millions of people, institutionalizing poverty and inequality and condemning our children and our children’s children to living in a dangerous, degraded world.
But if we embrace this knowledge and accept our responsibility, history will look back at this time in gratitude and admiration.
This is “Earth’s Hope”.
John D. Liu
December 11, 2007
Beijing
Michael Collins Uncategorized Climate change, Greenhouse gas, John D. Liu, Loess Plateau, Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, Rwanda